File: TrolleyProblem.swf-(530 KB, Game)
[_] All for one and one for all Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)06:24 No.1696285
Marked for deletion (old).
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)07:04 No.1696318
It didn't explain the ethical implications of each case...
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)07:08 No.1696320
You can't do this as a flash game r-tard, no one will take the situation seriously
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)07:16 No.1696328
Old problem is old. It should have worded it so that it was clear you were LETTING THEM DIE and
NOT KILLING THEM if you had chosen to not pull the lever. If this was supposed to demonstrate the
ethical problem of the equivalence of pushing someone in front of the trolley and switching the
trolley lever (they are indeed the same thing btw) it did a poor job of demonstrating such.
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)08:27 No.1696386
I saved my boyfriend and let 3 people die. Yay!
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)08:40 No.1696392
>>1696328
>> indeed the same thing
nope, the one you'd have to push down wasn't stupid enough to stand on the rails in the first
place.
So there is a difference.
I pushed no lever or person. GET OFF THOSE RAILS FAGGOTS! U GONNA DIE!!
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)08:45 No.1696398
This is a test to determin a Personality disorder in which you see humans as objects.
The original poblem consisted of some railroad workers who are working on the rails and dont
notice a train incoming. In the first part you could yell at the workers, but in a second
situation they couldnt hear you. The other alternative was throwing someone from the bridge to
warn the persons (at least lead their attention to the train) in the 3rd situation the only erson
available to shove was your important person.
Those with the personality disorder would chose Yell - Push - Push since they only see Humans as
objects.
The more you know
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)09:00 No.1696406
plotholes, plotholes everywhere
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)09:01 No.1696407
>>1696398
Why isn't there an opinion to try and stop the Trolley with all your might?
I would have chosen that one every time
>> [_] Guardian Angel 06/11/12(Mon)09:09 No.1696409
>try to do the right thing
>try to do the right thing
>try to do the right thing
...
>no option to untie people from the fucking train tracks
I CAN'T DO THE RIGHT THING, YOU FUCKING RETARDED GAME
>> [_] Random fggt 06/11/12(Mon)09:22 No.1696412
i pulled the lever every time, because three individuals have a higher chance of succeeding in
life and doing something worth while, however i did NOT push the person onto the track due to
that being flat out murder.
I knew the people already on the track were going to die, so seeing an option to have less
casualties, i had to take that.
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)09:29 No.1696415
>>1696407
you are standing on a brige and its not a trolley, its a train incoming
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)10:02 No.1696424
>>1696412
>that logic
Learn utility
>> [_] Ren 06/11/12(Mon)12:01 No.1696469
... So I killed the maximum amount of people.. Where's my highscore?!
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)12:34 No.1696494
>>1696398
>The other alternative was throwing someone from the bridge to warn the persons (at least lead
their attention to the train) in the 3rd situation the only erson available to shove was your
important person.
Real heroes would jump themselves.
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)12:35 No.1696496
>>1696469
I think you may have a different disorder to the one being described...
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)12:42 No.1696500
WTF IS THE POINT OF THIS?
i killed the obese guy because he is fat.
i saved my important person because that choice benefit myself. saving 3 unknown person isn't
going to do me any good in life, ethics are meaning less.
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)12:44 No.1696501
I killed my Dad, but he's a cunt.
>> [_] Anonymous 06/11/12(Mon)13:00 No.1696503
Why can't you kill all of them?
