File: Bad_Apple_Colour_Eng.swf-(7.79 MB, 320x240, Japanese)
[_] better? worse? Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)00:59 No.2570174
Marked for deletion (old).
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:05 No.2570179
Worse. They look like shit tbh.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:10 No.2570183
Celshading = shit.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:13 No.2570187
worse, it is not better in any way.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:17 No.2570191
looks fucking awful and the english sounds horrid
lasted like 30 seconds
>> [_] Repost Chan 10/21/14(Tue)01:17 No.2570192
>>2570179
Agreed. Strange how they put a large amount of effort into certain aspects, yet the models are so
low poly, it hurts. The fucking drop of saki looks like a disco ball. Part of the charm of the
original was how smooth the silhouettes were.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:22 No.2570200
How did that sound get encoded, holding a mic up to your speaker while playing a 16k stream of a
cassette recording?
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:31 No.2570212
kinda sucks.
i bet the OP or whoever put a shitload of effort into this for it to turn out less than appealing.
sorry dude
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:35 No.2570216
>>2570212
i didnt make it but ive always liked the song in this version better, quality of this flash is
pretty bad though. if anybody finds a better quality version that'd be awesome
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:42 No.2570220
>>2570192
Agreed. Not to mention we cannot even take solace in the music as the rip is loaded so hot every
dynamic is squashed to the same level. The cymbals sound like a seven year old with some old lead
pipes.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)01:56 No.2570232
worse.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)02:09 No.2570238
>>2570174
If nothing else it was interesting to see and English version of the song, and I have to admire
the lengths they went to fill in the blanks for some of the scenes. The song being low quality
seems to be intentional to match the quality of the models imo so Im not gonna knock it too much.
Needs some work yet but I can appreciate the effort put in to this.
>> [_] Repost Chan 10/21/14(Tue)02:29 No.2570250
>>2570212
>>2570216
>>2570220
>>2570238
>Everyone acknowledging someone's hard work despite a less than favorable result in a positive
manner
What the fuck? Is this really the internet? Am I actually on 4chan? What's going on?
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)02:46 No.2570257
>>2570250
Fuck off namefag, eat a dick.
This shit is shit, they are plasticky and have that fake motion that's in all the other flashes
using this shitty technology. Almost as bad as Carlito Carlito and Stomp to my beat [Loli].
All the edges are mine, bitches.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)02:57 No.2570268
>>2570179
I... I just wanted to upgoat. Oh god. What have I become.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)02:58 No.2570271
>>2570268
>upgoat
Swedish, clearly, you goatfucker.
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)03:08 No.2570284
>>2570271
....you mean arabic
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)03:08 No.2570285
1) Flash is shit quality. Audio and video are guaranteed to look like and sound like shit because
it's a shit medium.
2) Silhouettes are going to look a hell of a lot better for this. Even if we found out that this
video is actually the source video of the silhouettes, it's going to look like shit because
amateur 3d modeling. Take a look at 90% of MMD videos. The models would probably look a bit
better and more like source if anti-aliasing was used and motion blur to emulate the smoothness
of the original.
3) The english isn't as bad as everyone is whining about. It's still has some really shitty
things about it. For example, what I'm guessing sounds like autotune because she couldn't elevate
into the higher octaves is one shitty part. Another is how structured and script sounding the
lyrics sound in lower pitches of her singing. It's not as melodic as the source which is
unfortunate.
cont...
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)03:10 No.2570287
>>2570285
Overall: Nice try. I wouldn't have done both the color and english at the same time to have
spergs run it out of town. Having the original with english or the japanese vo with color would
have been a lot more accepting.
Learn to critic rather than shitpost you shitheads.
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)03:11 No.2570288
>>2570287
Critique*
Y-you too mate.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)03:14 No.2570291
>>2570288
>needing spell check to validate any form of intelligence
must be suffering to split hairs, eh?
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)03:29 No.2570299
>>2570291
You want to critique a work in-depth but discourage the critiquing of your basic technique and
function?
That's how you get represented as a faux-intellect with a superiority complex, numbnuts.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)03:46 No.2570307
>>2570299
>Ad Hominem
Nice try.
What I said was on-topic about the flash. What you're hair-splitting isn't and shitposting. Now
we're both guilty of being idiots because I'm responding.
I used the same format as:
>learn to japanese
>learn to english
>learn to critic
Also, you're using a name like a namefag, eat a dick.
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)04:02 No.2570314
>>2570307
Ad hominem's are only laughable when they aren't on point and/or relevant. This one was both. Not
my fault you can't take light criticism when you try to dish out heavy criticism.
>Namefag
>Implying that wasn't a prime fucking point of my post.
He wanted an angry review, so I gave him one.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)04:04 No.2570317
>>2570314
>Ad hominem's are only laughable when they aren't on point and/or relevant.
what?
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)04:05 No.2570318
>>2570314
is ur name really adam?
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)04:06 No.2570320
>>2570317
Nigga what?
>>2570318
No, Brosiris, or Robbie P. You're choice.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)04:09 No.2570321
>>2570320
your* :^)
i'll call u rob
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)04:11 No.2570324
>>2570314
>>2570320
Im pretty sure you tried to make a point using an ad hominem
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)04:28 No.2570336
>>2570324
Yeah probably.
>>2570321
Robbie P, bitch. Get it right!
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)04:32 No.2570337
>>2570336
sorry m8 but ur already rob.
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)04:34 No.2570339
>>2570337
Fuck. Things will never be the same.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)04:41 No.2570344
it sure looks like shit alright
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)05:15 No.2570369
>>2570174
Colour defeats the point, American accent sounds terrible.
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)05:21 No.2570371
>>2570285
Forget model quality, colors are not going to transform seamlessly no matter what you do (unless
you go all out with new tricky angles), and that's the fundamental flaw that destroys the whole
point.
>> [_] anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)05:23 No.2570373
worse
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)05:28 No.2570374
Now it's just another normal MMD. Shit/10.
>> [_] Hot2Trotsky 10/21/14(Tue)05:34 No.2570380
>>2570320
>"Brosiris"
(odd... I met someone once at a RenFaire who went by that handle. I ended up getting the name
"Depeche Brode")
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)06:25 No.2570409
>>2570380
>Brosiris
>Depeche BROde
Renfair are brony conventions, not Renaissance Fairs?
The fuck?
I called out brosiris because brosiris is brony on this board (probably even you) who is annoying.
Fuck 'em.
>> [_] Hot2Trorsky 10/21/14(Tue)06:34 No.2570418
>>2570409
All I know is afterhours at a Rennie, you can meet just about anyone, and they will probably have
booze in 'em or on 'em, or both. And I'll drink with just about anyone with good hooch. (E.g.,
Furries usually have at least 12 year Scotch, y'know.)
>> [_] Hot2Trotsky 10/21/14(Tue)06:38 No.2570421
(which is why I've said before that drinking parties in gensokyo remind me fondly of RenFaires...)
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)06:41 No.2570427
>>2570418
I'm puzzled by the misspelling of your name. Did you take it off so you could be anonymous for
another post on /f/f, and then type it back in to post here?
>> [_] Anonymous 10/21/14(Tue)06:48 No.2570432
>>2570257
Except Carlito is amazing.
>> [_] Hot2Trotsky 10/21/14(Tue)06:57 No.2570440
>>2570427
Heh... Didn't even notice the misspelling.
I have to manually re-enter my name every time because of my security settings.
>> [_] AdamB15 10/21/14(Tue)07:17 No.2570462
>>2570440
Sure.
I definitely believe you, fucking imposter.
